Skip to content Skip to footer

What is the Best Way to Teach A Child To Read?

Scott Cornfoot/

B.A. M. Sc., Ed. OCT, NCCP3

Our understanding of the best way of teaching a child to read has changed many times. The so-called “reading wars” have been raging for 200 years! Why have we not figured this out yet?

It’s complicated. There’s a fair bit of “we’ve always done it this way”, or “this is the most profitable way” and of course, “politicians want test scores”. Test scores are involved, of course. But, more importantly, we are continually learning more about the way our brains work and how good readers read. When we know better, we do better.

Three children looking at a reading workbook, best way to teach a child to read

A Comprehensive Guide to Teaching a Child to Read

Reading is one of the most important skills that a child can learn. Being able to read opens up a world of knowledge and imagination, and sets a foundation for lifelong learning. However, the process of teaching a child to read can be complex and there are many different approaches and theories about the best way to do it.

In this post, I will explore the history of the “reading wars” between different methods of reading instruction, the science of reading, and the five key components of effective reading instruction. By understanding the scientific basis for reading, we can provide children with the best possible foundation for becoming successful readers.

The Reading Wars

Throughout history, there have been two main theories about how to teach children to read: Whole Language and Phonics with Direct Instruction.

Whole Language is an approach that focuses on meaning and uses cues such as picture support and context to help children understand what they are reading. This approach was popular in the 1970s and 1980s and is based on the idea that reading should be a natural process that is learned through immersion and exposure.

Phonics with Direct Instruction, on the other hand, focuses on letter sounds and teaching children to sound out words, regardless of context. This approach is based on the idea that children need to be systematically taught the rules of the alphabet and how to use those rules to sound out words.

In recent years, most schools have adopted a blended approach known as Balanced Literacy, which combines elements of both Whole Language and Phonics with Direct Instruction. This approach recognizes the importance of both meaning and letter sounds in the reading process, and seeks to provide a balance between the two, but in my opinion, is just whole language in disguise.

The Science of Reading

The Science of Reading (SoR) is an approach to reading instruction that is based on decades of scientific research. This research has shown that reading is not a natural process and that children must be systematically taught the skills they need to become successful readers.

The Simple View of Reading theory, first proposed in 1986, suggests that reading comprehension is equal to the product of decoding and language comprehension. In other words, children need to be able to sound out words accurately and quickly in order to understand what they are reading.

SoR is based on the idea that there are five key components of effective reading instruction: phonemic awareness, phonics, vocabulary, fluency, and comprehension. By teaching these components in a systematic and research-based manner, educators can help children develop the skills they need to become confident and skilled readers.

Phonemic Awareness

Phonemic awareness is the ability to take apart and manipulate sounds in words orally. This is an important skill for children to have before they can learn phonics, as it helps them understand the sounds that make up words.

Activities that develop phonemic awareness include rhyming, counting syllables, and stretching out words to hear their individual sounds. For example, children can be asked to identify words that rhyme with a given word, or to count the number of syllables in a word.

Phonics

Phonics is the connection between the sounds of oral language and the printed letters on the page. Children who have a strong grasp of phonics are able to sound out words on the page, rather than relying solely on context or memory.

Phonics instruction typically involves teaching children the alphabet and the sounds associated with each letter. Children then practice sounding out words and connecting those sounds to the letters on the page.

Why is Vocabulary Important for Reading?

Vocabulary is the foundation of reading comprehension. Children who have a rich vocabulary are better able to understand and remember what they read. When children encounter new words, they have to make connections with words they already know and understand. By building a large vocabulary, children are able to make these connections more easily, which leads to improved reading comprehension.

How to Develop Vocabulary

  1. Read Aloud: Reading aloud to children exposes them to new words and their meanings in a natural and enjoyable way. Children can listen to and repeat new words, which helps them remember them.
  2. Introduce New Words: Teach children new words and their meanings in a systematic manner. This can be done through flashcards, word walls, or other visual aids.
  3. Encourage Questions: Encourage children to ask questions about words they don’t know. This helps them understand the meaning of the word and also builds their curiosity and critical thinking skills.
  4. Use Context Clues: When children encounter an unfamiliar word in a text, help them use context clues to figure out the meaning of the word. This helps them learn to figure out the meaning of words on their own, which will improve their vocabulary and reading comprehension.
  5. Play Word Games: Play word games such as Scrabble, Boggle, or Bananagrams to expose children to new words and improve their vocabulary skills.

Fluency

What is Fluency?

Fluency is the ability to read text accurately, quickly, and with expression. Fluent readers can read smoothly and effortlessly, allowing them to focus on the meaning of the text.

Importance of Fluency in Reading

Fluency is important because it improves reading comprehension by freeing up working memory. When children can read fluently, they can focus on the meaning of the text and make connections between what they are reading and what they already know. Fluent reading also improves reading speed and accuracy, which helps children become more confident and independent readers.

How to Develop Fluency

  1. Read Aloud: Encourage children to read aloud regularly. This helps build their confidence and fluency, and also gives them the opportunity to practice reading with expression.
  2. Timed Reading: Have children read texts for a set amount of time and then compare their reading speed and accuracy. This helps build fluency and gives children a sense of progress and achievement.
  3. Choral Reading: Choral reading involves having children read a text together in unison. This helps build fluency, and also helps children understand the rhythm and pacing of the text.
  4. Repeated Reading: Encourage children to read texts multiple times. This helps them become more familiar with the text, which will improve their fluency and comprehension.
  5. Reading with a Partner: Have children read with a partner, taking turns reading sentences or paragraphs. This helps build fluency and also gives children the opportunity to practice reading with expression.

 

Comprehension

What is Comprehension?

Comprehension is the ultimate goal of learning to read. Children who can comprehend what they read have a deep understanding of the text and can make connections between what they are reading and what they already know.

Importance of Comprehension

Comprehension is important because it helps children understand the meaning of what they are reading. Children who can comprehend what they read are better able to retain information and apply it to new situations. Comprehension also helps children develop critical thinking skills, as they must analyze and evaluate the information they are reading. Additionally, comprehension is an essential component of reading for pleasure and for academic success. Children who are able to comprehend what they read are able to understand and engage with more complex texts, which leads to a love of reading and greater success in school.

 

Techniques for Improving Comprehension

There are many techniques that can help improve comprehension, including:

  1. Asking questions before, during, and after reading: Asking questions before reading helps to activate prior knowledge and set a purpose for reading. During reading, children should be encouraged to stop and ask themselves questions to help them understand the text. After reading, children should be asked questions to assess their understanding and encourage further reflection.
  2. Summarizing: Summarizing helps children focus on the most important information in a text and understand the main ideas. Children should be encouraged to summarize what they have read in their own words, either orally or in writing.
  3. Visualizing: Encouraging children to visualize what they are reading can help them understand the text on a deeper level. Children should be encouraged to create mental images of characters, settings, and events.
  4. Connecting to personal experiences: Children should be encouraged to connect what they are reading to their own experiences, which helps to make the text more meaningful and relevant.
  5. Discussing: Discussing what they have read with others can help children consolidate their understanding and improve their comprehension. Children should be encouraged to share their thoughts and opinions with others and engage in discussions about what they have read.

 

Comprehension is the ultimate goal of learning to read and is essential for both academic and personal success. By focusing on the five key components of reading, including phonemic awareness, phonics, vocabulary, fluency, and comprehension, educators can help children become confident, skilled readers.

The Science of Reading and Comprehension

The Science of Reading approach recognizes the importance of comprehension as the ultimate goal of reading instruction. By teaching children the five key components of reading – phonemic awareness, phonics, vocabulary, fluency, and comprehension – educators can help children develop a deep understanding of the text they are reading. The Simple View of Reading theory, which is the foundation of the Science of Reading approach, suggests that reading comprehension is equal to the product of decoding and language comprehension. This means that in order for children to comprehend what they are reading, they must have strong phonemic awareness, phonics skills, vocabulary, and fluency.

The Science of Reading approach is an evidence-based approach that is designed to help children become confident, skilled readers. By focusing on the five key components of reading and the importance of comprehension, educators can ensure that children are equipped with the skills and knowledge they need to understand and retain what they read.

An image of the brain broken down into sections with arrows and labels explaining what each section of the brain is doing while it is decoding text

There are many parts of the brain involved in reading. The research to support the Science of Reading is vast.

In the world of education, change is hard and comes slowly. Of course, as there are everywhere, there are the “we’ve always done it this way” holdouts, but most teachers truly want to be doing what is best for their students. Some, like me, research on their own and adjust their classroom practices accordingly, despite the curriculum they are being given. In my classroom, I provide assessments and instruction to cover my curriculum, while maintaining a very clear focus on systematic, direct phonics instruction, vocabulary building, and rich discussions around the many quality books we read together. It’s an uphill battle – it’s time-consuming, expensive, and can potentially get you in hot water. However, it’s well worth it because my kids, for the most part, are reading!  

Systematic phonics instruction is the right way to go (which has been evident for decades), however, it takes a lot of time for publishers to write new curricula and even more time for school districts to adopt and implement them. This is useful to future students, who probably haven’t been born yet, but leaves current students hanging.

 

Teachers are overworked and too much is being asked of them these days. They need to be able to focus on the most important part of their job – teaching the students.

 

Right now, school systems should be spreading the word about what the current research saysand providing appropriate professional development. Most boards in the Province of Ontario focus on Math and Equity. It has been more than 5 years since there was a focus on literacy, we no longer have literacy coaches, those coaches have been given more responsibilities and are now called instructional coaches. Instructional Coaches should be working with teachers to implement the practices that we know work. We also need administrators willing to support (e.g., funding, professional development) teachers who use research-backed teaching methods

 

Taking Action

Now that we know all of this, what can you as a parent do to help teach your child to read? Here are a few practical steps you can take at home:

What Should I do is displayed on a chalk board.

It’s time for action! What should you do?

Make sure you talk to your children often and give them a variety of experiences. Background knowledge and vocabulary are major contributors to becoming a good reader.

  • Practice phonemic awareness:

  • Rhyming activities

  • Read rhyming books out loud and pause to let your child fill in the rhyme

  • Sing silly songs like the name game (Tom, Tom, bo bom, banana fanna fo fom, Tom!) or Willoughby Wallaby (Willoughby Wallaby Warah, an elephant sat on Sarah! – grab a stuffed animal and actually sit it on their head for extra laughs)

  • Play “Guess the Rhyming Word” by giving your child words that rhyme with the target word until they guess it.

  • Go back and forth saying as many rhyming words as you can think of until you run out of ideas (allow silly words if you want!)

  • Syllables

  • There are so many fun ways to practice orally breaking words up into syllables with your child! Have your child say a word out loud, and then say it again, clapping once for each syllable. You can also try stomping, jumping jacks, dance moves, punching, humming, hitting an instrument, sticking a straw into individual pieces of play dough, drawing dots, or pushing a piece of candy out of a row. You can even put your hand just under your chin and count the number of times your chin hits your hand. Practice with lots of words that have different numbers of syllables!

You can practice phonics in fun ways that are meaningful to your child:

  • Ask your child to bring you items around the house that start with a specific sound.

  • Write a variety of letters on a dry-erase board (or a window or door!). Call out a letter sound and have your child wipe off the letter they heard.

  • Ask them to write about their pictures, write name tags on their stuffed animals, or label household objects. Encourage them to sound out the words and write the sounds they hear.

  • When you run out of a specific food they like, ask your child to write it on the grocery list for you. Sound it out like they did the labels.

  • Always, always, always keep reading together! It increases the love of reading, improves vocabulary and background knowledge, and is a great way to spend quality time together with your child.

  • Be involved in your child’s school in a positive way. Don’t just pop in to say they’re not teaching reading correctly and then disappear again. Volunteer in classrooms, and get to know the staff. Usually, when a district is in the process of adopting a new curriculum, they will give parents the opportunity to review it and provide feedback. Do it and encourage your friends to as well! Be a supportive, encouraging voice at both the school and district levels.

For More Information

Are you interested now? Want to know more about what science says and what we can do about it? Check out these articles on the web

  • Hard Words: Why Aren’t Kids Being Taught to Read? Emily Hanford wrote this article in 2018 that brought reading research and how we are failing our kids to the forefront of the education community. Some have credited it with restarting the reading wars! She has since written several other articles, all about what the research says and highlighting programs that are succeeding or failing. Her articles are also available to listen to as podcasts.

  • What to do if your child’s school isn’t teaching reading right? was Hanford’s follow-up article for parents wanting more suggestions on what to do. (TL;DR – Get involved at district and administrative levels, and don’t be combative with your child’s teacher.)

  • How the Science of Reading Helps Kids Learn to Read is an easy-to-understand description of what the research is teaching us. (Remember that they are also trying to sell you their product, but they do have many useful articles about teaching kids to read)

  • What is the Science of Reading? Timothy Shanahan is one of the top literacy researchers today. His website is full of helpful posts about reading instruction, often responses to questions from parents or teachers.